让AI搭3D世界,最强模型成功率不到60%
让AI根据一句话搭出一个能走进去的3D世界,听起来很科幻,但现有评测都太简单,看不出真实水平。这篇论文造了个更狠的考场:2616个3D资产、6828条多模态指令,让AI自己规划布局、调用工具、看渲染结果再调整。结果连GPT-5.5和Qwen3.8-Max都翻车,成功率不到60%,瓶颈卡在精确编辑3D物体上。但有个反转:用强化学习微调的开源小模型VibeWorlder-30B,反而超过了闭源巨头。这不是你明天能用的产品,但它划出了AI从“聊天”到“动手造世界”的进度条。
📄 原文摘要(英文)
Constructing an interactive 3D open world from a user query is important. However, existing methods are primarily evaluated on idealized, simple queries, making it difficult to systematically analyze and compare how multimodal agents understand user intent, use 3D tools, and reason over textual and visual 3D world information. To this end, we propose VibeWorlding, a unified framework for benchmarking and training vibe worlding agents: a multimodal agent that can autonomously infer user intent, plan scene layout, invoke 3D tools, and reflect on the multimodal feedback in a multi-turn agent-environment interaction process. To achieve this, we first build VWE-BENCH, a benchmark of 2,616 high-quality 3D assets, 323 human-annotated seed 3D worlds, and 6,828 reverse-synthesized multimodal user queries, split into verified queries with ground-truth and unverified queries with carefully designed rubrics. Moreover, we develop VibeWorlding-Gym, a joint multimodal RL post-training framework that integrates (1) a sandbox environment unifying asset retrieval, editing, and image rendering as MCP tools, and (2) a rubric-based verifier that combines physical feasibility and intent fulfillment verification, supporting both fair model evaluation and scalable multimodal RL reward service. Our experiments show that current frontier MLLMs are far from solving the vibe worlding agent task, with even GPT-5.5 and Qwen3.8-Max reaching below 60% success rate, and trace the bottleneck to precise 3D world editing. We further find that RL training can ease this weakness and enable open-source MLLMs to even surpass closed-source frontiers: our VibeWorlder-8B is comparable to frontier MLLMs, while our flagship VibeWorlder-30B-A3B attains the best overall Pass@1 among all evaluated models.